home | about | contact us | submit a resource | search | browse resources | login

CSTC Review Form Sample Only: This form is not active Thank you for taking the time to review a submission to the CSTC. Provide the following information about the resource you reviewed. Refer to the note to reviewers if you have questions. Required information is indicated with an asterick (*).

Submission Information *
	Title
	ID #
	CSTC Editor	I don't know Scott Grissom Deborah Knox Edward Fox
Reviewer Information * (confidential)
	Your Name
	Mailing Address (for thank you letter, it remains confidential)
	Your E-mail
Classification
	Select appropriate categories for the submission. Use your best judgment. Your categories will be compared with what the author and other reviewers suggest.
	Subject Area	general literature hardware systems organization software data theory mathematics information systems methodologies applications milieux
	Knowledge Unit	Algs & Data Structures Architecture Artificial Intelligence Database Human-Computer Communication Numerical Computation Operating Systems Programming Languages Software Engineering
	Platform	cross platform UNIX / X11 Windows 95 / NT DOS Mac OS HTML client Java Virtual Machine
Ratings *
	Rate the submission on the following criteria. Refer to reviewer criteria for clarification of the categories.
	Effectiveness	poor fair average good excellent
	Accuracy	poor fair average good excellent
	Clarity	poor fair average good excellent
	Reusability	poor fair average good excellent
	Originality	poor fair average good excellent
	Overall	reject weak reject neutral weak accept accept
	Provide additional comments to explain the above ratings.
Reviewer Comments *
	Please answer the following questions to provide additional information to the authors and Editors. What was your initial impression of the resource page. Were the objectives clear? Were the instructions for obtaining and using the resource clear? How long did it take you to install the resource (if applicable)? Briefly explain how you reviewed the resource. How much time did you spend? Did you actually use it in class or simply look it over? Did any students have an opportunity to use it? What specific suggestions do you have for the author to improve the resource?
Confidential Comments
	Any further confidential comments you want to share with the Editors.
Thank You
	Click on the "Submit Review" button to send your review to a CSTC editor. You will receive immediate confirmation with a summary of your review.